
President Asif Ali Zardari and Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif held an urgent meeting at Aiwan-e-Sadr on Thursday to contain a political crisis triggered by explosive remarks from Pakistan Peoples Party Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari, who warned that dividing Sindh could lead to a bloodbath.
The hastily arranged talks brought together the country’s top leadership after Bilawal’s statements at Karachi Press Club set off a firestorm within the ruling coalition. Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi, who has become the central target of Bilawal’s criticism, also attended the meeting in what appeared to be an attempt at damage control.
Both leaders agreed that all outstanding matters would be resolved through dialogue and mutual consultation, according to a statement from the President’s office. The carefully worded announcement came as tensions between coalition partners threatened to destabilize the government.
The controversy erupted after Bilawal publicly warned against any attempt to administratively divide Sindh, claiming the government was considering a 28th constitutional amendment for that purpose. He also alleged that the PPP had been coerced into supporting the 27th Amendment, contradicting the government’s narrative of consensus-building.
Bilawal’s remarks drew sharp rebukes from senior government figures. Adviser to the Prime Minister Rana Sanaullah suggested the PPP chairman’s statements could lead to his disqualification, while Defence Minister Khawaja Asif questioned Bilawal’s moral authority given the PPP’s 18-year rule in Sindh.
The dispute centers on Interior Minister Naqvi’s repeated calls for creating new provinces to address what he describes as a collapsed governance system. Speaking at the Pakistan Economic Summit in July, Naqvi argued that the existing administrative structure had failed after decades of poor performance.
Naqvi’s position has found support from the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan, which has long advocated dividing Sindh into multiple provinces. MQM-P leader Mustafa Kamal renewed those demands even before Naqvi’s public statements.
The Sindh Assembly responded in September by passing a resolution firmly rejecting any division of the province. Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah declared there would be no compromise on Sindh’s geographical unity.
Bilawal has since doubled down on his position in multiple television interviews, telling government officials to “calm down” and listen to his concerns as one of the country’s largest political stakeholders. He rejected calls for a referendum on the issue, arguing such mechanisms have never been used democratically in Pakistan’s history.
The meeting between Zardari and Shehbaz also discussed regional developments, particularly the situation in the Middle East, though the statement provided no details.
Prime Minister Shehbaz’s scheduled visit to Karachi on Friday has been postponed indefinitely, with no new date announced. The visit was meant to address various issues between the PPP and PML-N, including matters related to federal-provincial relations.
The postponement signals that despite Thursday’s agreement on dialogue, significant differences remain between the coalition partners. The controversy has exposed fault lines within the ruling alliance at a time when the government faces mounting economic and political challenges.
MQM-P added fuel to the fire by reiterating Thursday that its demand for new provinces remains final, suggesting the issue is far from resolved despite the leadership’s commitment to consultation.
Whether dialogue can bridge the widening gap between coalition partners or whether Bilawal’s warnings represent a fundamental break in the alliance remains unclear. What is certain is that the province division debate has become the most serious test yet of the coalition’s stability.


